One of the most memorable fights that my ex-husband and I ever had occurred on the Valentines Day of our final year together. I remember the gift I gave him and when it was his turn to reciprocate I was thrilled to find a pair of sapphire earrings. Well, thrilled that is until I realized they were real.
I was livid! How could he have spent so much on a gift for me when this same person yelled at me for spending $3 on a drink from Starbucks once a week. The same person who made me take back the little black dress that I was so excited to wear at my first San Francisco Christmas party. The indulgent purchase totaled $120 and his comment “you spent HOW MUCH on something that looks like THAT on you!” had me in tears as I gave in and got the refund he requested. While coffee and clothing were something I held in esteem within modest amounts, I didn’t even like jewelry. I felt somehow violated that he knew so little about me. How could our priorities be so different? Later when I found out that his girlfriend picked them out for me it began to make sense. Happily that story ended with the girlfriend keeping the earrings (and the husband) and as recompense I got my second piece of art which I still love dearly.
I haven’t thought about this in years but it is a common theme which translates to engagement rings, electrical equipment, apts., my inability to celebrate birthdays and holidays, and my negative judgement of anyone attempting to take me to trendy restaurants. Basically I feel if I can’t pay may way — regardless of whether I do or not — that I don’t want it. I admit to having an abnormally high level of independence and the joke that I’d allow myself to bleed to death before calling for help is not far off from the truth but where does it come from?
Not to blame but to remark, I do think shifting from parents who gave more than they had and encouraged me to buy what I wanted to a financially controlling husband was a bit extreme. By the time I got separated, I was making a rather remarkable salary and enjoyed a lifestyle of eating out every meal with friends, a great apt. and the freedom to buy whatever little black or other colored dress, shoe or purse that intrigued me.
This lasted for a few years until I fell in love again with art. I’d been collecting for years but once I made the decision to pursue art full time my priorities quickly shifted. I translated every $200 I spent to the cost of wine and invitations to host an event and yes, it made for lots of nights alone while my friends went out but for the first time I felt I understood the value of money and my personal values surrounding it. Over the years I’ve experienced feast and famine — I prefer feast — but through these experiences my relationship to money and gifts has evolved which brings me to today’s drama.
The day started innocently enough, dogs walked, coffee consumed and my favorite Saturday morning pilates class. I had a few errands to take care of, a day of art planned and all was well with the world until I received a text asking if I’d been home. Don’t ask me why but I knew it could only mean that some well intentioned person was trying to deliver flowers. Now to be clear, I have NOTHING against flowers in fact it is one of the charms of living in NY as they brighten every corner bodega and if you know where to shop fresh tulips can be yours for $6 a bundle. I mean who doesn’t like flowers BUT delivered flowers are expensive and for someone who has struggled to eat and pay rent for the past few years it seems like an extravagancy akin to lighting candles with dollar bills. Okay, okay extreme example but I flew into an irrational rage. I truly know they meant well. They thought it would be a nice surprise but I guess they ended being more surprised.
I realize I seem horribly ungrateful but for the money spent I could have paid my electric bill or bought dog food for a month or groceries or something I needed. Terminally unromantic but it seems a terrible waste and as my blood continues to boil, my eyes begin to fill with tears of shame.
Perhaps this is all too practical but let’s face it gift giving makes the giver feel good but shouldn’t the receiver also be happy? In my opinion, it should be about giving what the person needs or wants not forcing them to accept what they want you to have. It’s the same argument every Christmas with my aunt who insists on sending something for me to open on Christmas morning. Year after year I plead but she still ships a large box of “stuff”. She thinks it’s for my entertainment but as the items end up in the lobby of my apt. building or donated the week after, I have such guilt for the wastefulness that it fills me with dread. I know she means well but a card with $20 would be a far better choice and the shipping is virtually free.
So why am I so upset? I do feel I have a valid point on the misuse of consumerism but there’s also an argument about allowing someone to show affection, to do something for you and to be loving enough to simply say thank you. Have I really become the equivalent of an emotional cutter unable to accept loving behavior without hurting myself? I wish it were that simple to bleed myself of this behavior but it continues to pulse through my veins as my independent — okay moronically stubborn — heart continues to beat. This same heart that will beat until the dreaded hallmark holiday passes. Perhaps next year I’ll allow someone to do something for me but for now NO FLOWERS PLEASE.